CAMERON WINTER AT CARNEGIE HALL Feels Like Going To Church

There has been (too) much discourse surrounding the meteoric rise and potential psy-op success of Geese, the New York rock band led by 24-year-old frontman Cameron Winter. Many critics of Winter’s distinct vocal range and strange lyrical poeticism seem convinced he can’t be sincerely admired by his rabid fans. The cult of Geese exploded seemingly overnight as Winter released his solo album, Heavy Metal, and the fourth Geese record, Getting Killed, within 12 months of one another. Despite being at the center of both albums, they couldn’t feel more distinct as complete bodies of work. Recording those two albums one month apart seemingly wasn’t enough for Winter. In the midst of the Getting Killed Tour, Winter took the stage at Carnegie Hall towards the end of 2025 for a solo show primarily made up of reworked songs from Heavy Metal. On that intensely cold New York evening in December, director Paul Thomas Anderson, co-producer Benny Safdie, and more were seen with 35mm cameras in tow, laser-focused on Winter and his sleek, jet-black piano on stage. It’s in this singular performance that PTA and Winter seemingly capture a genuine slice of heaven.

The excitement of this performance’s audience is palpable as we see them make their way into the legendary concert hall for a performance that had much mystique behind it. Winter himself is admittedly an acquired taste. It’s the central issue so many of his detractors bring up when insisting that Geese or Winter’s fans are partaking in some elaborate bit. But it cannot be overstated how impressive it is that Winter even has this opportunity to begin with. He is one of the youngest headliners to ever grace the acclaimed stage (Bob Dylan has him slightly beat as an example of his competition). And this is obviously not the type of scenario that’s simply handed to somebody because of rapid acclaim due to online algorithms and streaming boosts. It’s instead exemplary of how idiosyncratic a voice Winter wields in today’s music scene; one that is inundated with trend-following artists, the likes of which are rewarded for catering to an algorithm. That Geese and Winter’s success exists in direct opposition to such restrictive edges is both thrilling and moving. All this potential and wonder is equally captured in the grainy beauty of PTA’s film.

Cameron Winter at Carnegie Hall finds PTA enamored by the mystifying presence of Winter on stage. His slender frame appears miniscule compared to the cavernous stage he is on and the more expansive, ever-rising auditorium full of fans at his back. As he swiftly plays the piano and belts out modern poetry, his pain is felt through his delivery and in the blank gaze of his eyes. It’s captured with such clarity and reverence by the film. PTA observes the intimacy of this performance and conveys it to an audience deeply appreciative of being let into such a mindset. Winter cannot hide behind any irony or cinematic magic tricks here. The reason being is that many of the individual songs performed are impressively captured in long, single takes. One even sees PTA returning to the magic of his introductory oner in Boogie Nights, where at one point the camera slowly yet excitedly makes its way down an aisle to swallow up as much of Winter in the frame as possible while he bares his soul to an audience marveling at this special event they’re witnessing occur. The occasional moments PTA turns the camera on the audience are each distinctly special in this regard. Winter is relying on their gaze as much as they are salivating for and, ultimately embracing, his next artistic choice. Whether it be an impromptu whip to a fan overcome with the essential need to provide a standing ovation or witnessing their nearly-still beauty an entire aisle rapt with silent attention and wonder, this is an audience who has found themselves fully tapped into the necessary wavelength of an event that feels spiritual in nature. After all, what is more akin to churchgoing than hearing somebody speak in metaphor and didactic asides over heavenly music and brilliant lighting?

The lighting in particular of this performance must be highlighted. For much of the runtime, there is a single spotlight on Winter. It is almost constantly drawing all eyes towards him. The warmth of the film photography, and the roadshow 35mm presentation of the film itself, makes the evening and PTA’s film feel all the more special. But when Winter becomes enveloped in darkness as the sole light in Carnegie Hall slowly dims, one is overcome with the crushing sense of isolating pain being captured in Winter’s music. Struggling to make out Winter’s shadow amidst the sea of darkness represents a striking example of performance in its own right, beyond just looking marvelous. When the lights go out completely, it’s thrilling. The same can be said for Winter’s performance of “Nina + Field of Cops”, which is perhaps the standout track of the evening in my humble opinion. As Winter’s piano notes build and build to the point of immense pressure, PTA whisks a camera through a set of doors opening at the last possible second for our pleasure to capture the artist in complete detail, warmly lit by the spotlight as the crescendo of the song beckons us towards being allowed to release our breath. It’s a dazzling display of talent from a filmmaker who knows how to make a moment feel magical for his audience. Importantly, such occasional flair from PTA never steals a sense of the reality this evening was occurring within. That’s ultimately all Cameron Winter at Carnegie Hall is. It is a document of December 11, 2025: a day where a bit of magic happened on stage. Luckily, it was captured for cinema audiences to partake in through the beauty of another integral communal experience. There is no ulterior motive here. There is no psy-op. Winter simply had some things to get off his chest and did so with complete sincerity. PTA and his collaborators were merely there to capture it as plainly as possible. When the work is so vulnerable, allowing an artist the opportunity to bare it all for their audience, there’s an irreplaceable value to simply portraying it exactly as it happened. PTA has long been one of our greatest writers who acutely explores the human condition in profoundly meaningful ways. The marvelous and revelatory experience that is seeing Winter do the same through his performance makes this cinematic pairing feel like kismet. It would appear Cameron Winter at Carnegie Hall has everything necessary to understand both artists just a bit better. And for those who are unfamiliar with Winter’s work, hopefully it is the doorway to discovering plenty of exciting, distinct, real music.

Janus Films and Criterion are releasing Cameron Winter at Carnegie Hall in a city-by-city 35mm tour that began on November 20.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *